McINTYRE’S BOOKS PRESENTS

Pete Mock’s 8th Annual Beltie Mystery Prize

A person in a fedora and checkered shirt sits in a leather chair, pointing at a stack of books on their lap. The shelf behind them is filled with more books, suggesting a bookstore or library setting. Fearrington Village

PETE’S 2025 HIT LIST

  • Ramona Emerson, Exposure

  • Eryk Pruitt, Blood Red Summer

  • Eli Cranor, Broiler

  • Abir Mukherjee, Hunted

  • Juliet Grames, The Lost Boy of Santa Chionia

  • K.C. Constantine, Another Day’s Pain

  • Joanna Wallace, You’d Look Better as a Ghost

  • Peter May, The Black Loch

Want to read them all yourself? Or gift them along?
Click below, friends.

grab the bundle button

Pete Mock, McIntyre’s book buyer and mystery aficionado, selects the best mystery, thriller, noir, procedural, or true crime novel of the year.

“As the year slowly wanes, the days darken early, and arctic chills cover the land and cause us to huddle inside around the fireplace, what a better time than now to share the nominees for the 2024 Beltie Prize that we at McIntyre’s award to the best mystery of the past year. We’ve been doing this since 2018 and like every year it’s tough to narrow all the titles that are deserving down to just eight. Night after night, tossing and turning, arguing the merits and demerits, slowly the field is narrowed and themes revealed. This year social and cultural issues dominate as our authors channel their inner Dickens in fewer pages and elucidate quite eloquently the supposed dichotomy between what has seemingly become us vs. them, which is what the mystery genre is so very good at doing. But the list is not just that. Like all past years, there is something for everyone here, and like every year, we offer up the Beltie in the hope that you, the reader, find something new, something different, and most of all, that you will discover new authors you can then read for years to come.

Now, onto the list!”  — Pete

Beltie Mystery Prize 2025 Longlist logo on the left with yellow text and details. On the right, the book cover of "Exposure" by Ramona Emerson featuring a security camera, a stop sign, and a city aerial view. Fearrington Village
The logo for McIntyre's Books features a circular design with the phrase "storied indie since 1989" in the center. The outer circle contains the bookstore name and website, "MCINTYRE'S BOOKS" and "www.mcintyresbooks.com. Fearrington Village

2025 NOMINEES









PREVIOUS BELTIE MYSTERY PRIZE WINNERS

Killer Winners from Years Past

Split image featuring the "Beltie Mystery Prize 2024 Winner" on the left with scissors and bottles motif, and the book cover of "Better the Blood" by Michael Bennett on the right, with a red spiral design. Fearrington Village

ABOUT PETE MOCK

Judge & Jury

A man wearing a black jacket, jeans, and a hat stands next to a skeleton dressed in a blue and yellow hooded cloak with a feather boa. They are in a bookstore with various books on display. A chalkboard behind them features hand-written quotes and messages. Fearrington Village

Why are you drawn to mysteries/suspense?
I love the suspense and intrigue. I grew up reading my dad’s books and he was always getting Robert Ludlum, Fredrick Forsyth, Ken Follett and I’ve never stopped. Instead of television, I relax with a good mystery/thriller.

What is the Beltie Mystery Prize you might ask?
It’s an award given to the best mystery book of the year as chosen by Pete Mock, our Mystery Guru. We announce the finalists every fall, with the Beltie Prize Winner announcement at the end of the year. Want to read up on this year’s nominees and all the past winners and nominees (it’s a mighty fine bunch of mysteries, we can assure you)? You can find them all here. We thought that given his prestigious status as Guru you might like to know a bit more about him. Read on for an introduction.

Tell us about how you keep track of the 100 mysteries you read each year?
I don’t really keep a log. For The Beltie Prize I do keep what I call my super long list which is any book that stood out for me and which I consider when it comes time to whittle things down to the final eight. This past year I had 37 titles on that list.

That’s a lot of reading! Where do they grow readers like this?
Born in Vermont, grew up in New Hampshire, have lived in Chapel Hill since the 9th grade.

When did you first discover you loved to read?
I’ve been a reader since at least five years old. I remember reading Charlotte’s Web to my siblings when I was six.

Who are your favorite all-time writers?
Mystery-wise, James Lee Burke (one of the best writer’s in this country bar none), Jo Nesbo, and Mo Hayder. My favorite mystery ever is probably is Go With Me by Castle Freeman. Great plot, spot-on dialogue, and an ending that made me smile. Other than mysteries: Gabriel Garcia Marquez, historian Russell Shorto, Robert Penn Warren for All the King’s Men.

;